“This should not have happened,” Becker said. “It is a disaster for the people whose data is being exposed. In the worst case, the consequences can be severe.”
What we consider before using anonymous sources. Do you know the information sources? What is their motive for telling us? Has it proven reliable in the past? Can we confirm the information? Even as it satisfies these questions, The Times uses anonymous sources as a last resort. The reporter and at least one editor know the identity of the source.
Of the six devices the researchers purchased on eBay — four SEEKs and two HIIDEs, for portable interagency identification equipment — two of the SEEK II devices had sensitive data on them. A second SEEK II, with site metadata showing it was last used in Jordan in 2013, appears to contain the fingerprints and iris scans of a small group of US service members.
When The Times arrived, an American whose biometric scan had been found on the device confirmed that the data was likely his. He previously worked as a naval intelligence expert and said his data, and that of any other American on the devices, was likely collected during a military training course. The man, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he still works in the intelligence business and was not authorized to speak publicly, asked that his biometric profile be deleted.
Military officials said the only reason these devices could contain data on Americans was because they were used during training sessions, which is common practice to prepare for their use in the field.
According to the Defense Logistics Agency, which handles millions of dollars in excess Pentagon materials each year, devices like the SEEK II and HIIDE should never have made it to the open market—let alone an online auction site like eBay. Instead, all biometric collection equipment is meant to be destroyed on site when military personnel no longer need it, as is the case with other electronic devices that previously contained sensitive operational information.
It’s unclear how eBay sellers acquired these devices. The 2632-profile device was sold by Rhino Trade, a Texas surplus equipment company. The company’s treasurer, David Mendez, said it bought the SEEK II at a government equipment auction not realizing that the decommissioned military device would have sensitive data.
“I hope we don’t do anything wrong,” he said.
The SEEK II came with US Forces information from Tech-Mart, an Ohio-based eBay seller. Tech-Mart store owner Ayman Arafa refused to disclose how he or the other two devices he sold to researchers were acquired.
“Coffee trailblazer. Certified pop culture lover. Infuriatingly humble gamer.”
